I don't think it's the same thing though? I mean both Jason's triples and Nathan's quads are technically flawless, some people just think the extra quad revolution gives too many additional points on the PCS side. But Shoma has some real problems with the technical quality of the jumps, and the rotation as well. And I say this as a huge Shoma fan; he is definitely my favourite Japanese skater and one of my favourite male skaters overall. I would just like to see him fix his teknik a little.
I get what you are saying. I just feel it's a little hypocritical to say it's not all about quads/technical components then nitpick Shoma's flawed jumps. I get a feeling that technical components seem to matter more when it's against a skater who's not a favorite (i.e. Shoma) but certain skaters get a pass on technical (Brown). Just my opinion.