- Joined
- Mar 20, 2014
PERFECT SCORE, BEEYOTCHES!
I know it’s nationals, so before anyone wants to grumble about inflation... in the jello pit, NOW!
"Welcome to _______ Figure Skating National Championships!"
Seriously, let's just enjoy the moment
2018 Canadian Nationals Senior Free Dance
- Thread starter Mango
- Start date
"Welcome to _______ Figure Skating National Championships!"
Seriously, let's just enjoy the moment
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2014
Loved it. I really approve of the change. The denouement downer ending was just not cutting it for me.
I thought W/P were great and I'm happy for G/P. The James Bond program needs some more time though.
I also really liked S/F and in the earlier group I liked A/W a lot. I'm happy with the top five.
So Tracy thinks V/M are the best ever. Big deal. It's not like they are going to get a special prize for that. People need to stop falling for hype.
I thought W/P were great and I'm happy for G/P. The James Bond program needs some more time though.
I also really liked S/F and in the earlier group I liked A/W a lot. I'm happy with the top five.
So Tracy thinks V/M are the best ever. Big deal. It's not like they are going to get a special prize for that. People need to stop falling for hype.
- Joined
- Jul 28, 2003
I agree about V/M's body of work and bringing dance back to ice dance. It's been refreshing to watch them over the years with their many styles and influences on other dance teams. It's great when skaters "push the envelope" so to speak and leave their mark on FS perhaps that is what Tracy is saying. Since it is Canadian Nationals they earned their top marks and respect from their fellow competitors. I also wish they'd picked different music than Moulin Rouge for their last FD at the Olympics especially when P/C are skating to Moonlight Sonata, how does one top Beethoven, musically speaking?
Look for his 2005 Canadian nationals skate — his best performance of the program. If he'd skated it like that at worlds that year...
It or miss though. Still nightmares about their 1986 OSP.
Davis/White don't belong anywhere near that list. But the rest, yes, agree.
These two and V/M are the only three I would guarantee places in the pantheon of ice dance legends.
I was never a G/P lover. Speed and theatrics do not great dancers make in my book. Before I would include them or even Davis/White (who I really enjoy!) I would include Usova/Zhulin. He was one of the most natural, captivating dancers I have ever seen and she had one of the best leg lines in history. Their 1992 Olympic free dance is a masterclass on lines and beautiful positions. K/P was just amazing however (but the Duchesnays were a hot mess that year). U/Z's 1993 Blues for Klook was pure heat and brilliance. It's too bad that they didn't have better material in 1994.
Davis/White should not be considered close to being "legendary" along with couples like K/P or T/D, and G/P and the like. Unless acrobatics on ice and inferior skating and expression is the new "legendary".
Davis/White I think are the weakest OGM in all of ice dancing history.
After watching the GP, I did not think Moulin Rouge could be salvaged. But the music cuts now are so much better that it is so unfortunate that they didn't debut this version during the GP.
Davis/White I think are the weakest OGM in all of ice dancing history.
After watching the GP, I did not think Moulin Rouge could be salvaged. But the music cuts now are so much better that it is so unfortunate that they didn't debut this version during the GP.
- Joined
- Aug 18, 2017
Davis/White should not be considered close to being "legendary" along with couples like K/P or T/D, and G/P and the like. Unless acrobatics on ice and inferior skating and expression is the new "legendary".
Their second mark start value should have been a 5.5 because of her posture alone
- - - Updated - - -
You guys are coming hard tonight!!
- Joined
- Aug 18, 2017
V/M's programs are much more difficult than the ones they have had in the past under Zoueva. The midline step sequence in the Moulin Rouge FD is harder than it looks and much more difficult than what Zoueva does with her teams (which is just recycling same turns in the same predictable direction presumably to make the points-collecting process less arduous for both the skater and the judge).
V/M's dances these past two seasons have more choreography and difficulty than what Zoueva did for them. Much more coherent and less looking like an exercise of choreography by numbers.
V/M's dances these past two seasons have more choreography and difficulty than what Zoueva did for them. Much more coherent and less looking like an exercise of choreography by numbers.
Last edited by a moderator:
Good to see G/P back with a stronger vehicle.
The Bond music is overused but at least it moves and has highlights to showcase some of their innovative lifts and positions. I still think Paul's character can grow, and they need to get those twizzles together but I was worried about the old program
The Bond music is overused but at least it moves and has highlights to showcase some of their innovative lifts and positions. I still think Paul's character can grow, and they need to get those twizzles together but I was worried about the old program
You don't like D/W, we get it, but if you think they are the weakest OGM in ice dancing, obviously you need a history lesson in Olympic ice dancing:handw:
D/W are not only the weakest OGM in ice dancing history, but I think the weakest by a long mile and will hold this title for as long as ice dancing remains a sport in the Olympics. They are already forgotten and I think the reason they did not try to defend their (questionable) Olympic title is because well, they knew that they would get quashed. They saw the high, unprecedented level of skating, expression, and style exhibited by P/C in the 2015 and 2016 years, and with V/M's comeback in 2017 in which they beat P/C, it was very wise for D/W to opt out. Ice dancing experienced an anomaly with D/W's "win" in 2013-2014, where ice dance reverted backwards to not being ice dancing at all, but some very mangled conception of what ice dancing is. I think that many (perhaps skaters, coaches, and those who spent much time in the sport) and fans were troubled during this time. Articles from skating coaches and skaters popped up criticizing if not D/W, then the style of ice dancing that came to be under D/W's years. Very legitimate, of course. Except of course, the Americans. They needed badly for a first ever ice dance gold and needed an ice dance team to prop up. The likes of Phil Hersh and Christine Brennan contributed to this US media spin, of course. Coincidentally, they are my least favorite sports "journalists" of all time.
After D/W's retirement, ice dancing has become ice dancing again, and progressed and advanced even further thanks to P/C. Now that V/M have made a successful comeback, these two teams will contribute to possibly the greatest ever ice dancing rivalry that we have ever seen. The 2018 Olympic performances between V/M and P/C will be one for the ages that we have not seen ever. It will truly be a spectacular and extraordinary event the likes with which we have never witnessed.
These flames are too hot for my old bones to handle
Those poor jerks at all those skating events and companies who keep giving them endorsements and shows. They are so ignorant on ice dancing!
I'm sure Meryl is crying herself to sleep on her airweave mattress knowing she's part of the the worse OGM ice dancing pair ever.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2014
I have never been a D/W fan. They leave me cold but I don't think anyone can argue that they are great technicians and great ambassadors for the ice dancing community.
I'm not sure why anyone would think D/W were not deserving winners in 2014. (even though I personally wanted the French team to win because I loved the Little Prince)
I'm not sure why anyone would think D/W were not deserving winners in 2014. (even though I personally wanted the French team to win because I loved the Little Prince)
Similar threads
- Sticky
- Sticky
- Sticky
