I suppose Kaori's sudden PCS jump looks suspect, but I'll come out and say I think that's the PCS she has always deserved (for a clean program, at least - I'm fine with shaving off some points for today since she popped and was generally pretty tight). Satoko, of course, should be right up there as well, and I'm heartbroken to see that she has seemingly been abandoned. (I think another part of this may be that they want to keep Kaori competitive for the years to come due to their acknowledgement of her potential while they've set their mind to abandon Satoko, which is... heartbreaking in another way.)
Regarding the argument that "the Japanese ladies blew their chance so it's their own fault," though. Of course they are to blame for their own mistakes. This, though, irks me because it means when other ladies' PCS remain constantly inflated, the Japanese ladies (as well as most other ladies) have to comparatively do so much better for them to shine. This is true, of course, everywhere - some skaters' scores and PCS will take ridiculous plunges for one small error while others' will get held up through bad programs as well as scratchy and bombing competitions. I suppose this is a part of why Sui/Han's victory felt so particularly personal to me yesterday - barring a completely perfect program, which they somehow miraculously delivered, they would have likely lost and people would probably have called it justified because they would have not been perfect. Yes, I think they could have lost over a single hiccup, even though nobody (except real life Sui/Han) was perfectly clean in Pairs last night. Yes, I think that's unfair, considering the similar levels of command the teams had over the tech, and the world of difference between their levels of artistic expression.
I totally feel the same about everything. But somehow I feel that Zhenya skated cleaner overall (no big mistakes and was the only one punished in the sp and lp by the tech controllers) so her medal isn't a big injustice for me.