https://ibb.co/6tXWDN9
https://ibb.co/6tXWDN9
Seriously?
As for edge - top down view is still isn't appropriate to determine it IMO - but let's agree with flat for argument's sake. First, penalty for it is much less than UR, second - I don't care about edge here, I care about FALSE call. Missing something else does not and should not justify it.
As I said above - I hate false calls first and foremost. Everything else is insignicant in light of such judging abomination. That, and without frontal/rear view of an edge I don't feel enough confidence to make strong statements. With "UR", on other hand, I have 200% proof which don't let place for doubt.
No, it isn't. For example do not noticing someone's crimes and falsely accusing someone with counterfeited evidence are so vastly different conceptions with so vastly different degrees of fault and outcomes that I don't even know where to begin
Returning to sport example - simply put in one case you just helping someone with not so good performance to keep what he already did albeit poorly; in other - you are destroying what someone is already deserved and put his work into. Are they vastly different notions? Without doubt - they are.
Firstly, you're ascribing malice to any call you don't agree with, which is inherently nonsensical. Differences of opinion are not "counterfeited evidence".
In real time? Nah, there isn't. What differs various lutzes between each other in eyes of common spectator is their height, distance and landing. And that is what should be reflected in scores first and foremost. Incomprehensible scores fluctuations due to invisible jump technicalities having zero impact on overall performance impressions isn't what is gonna increase fs popularity, believe me. In slo-mo? Yes, there is. But why care about slo-mo anyway? It should concern only tech specialists - not even judges since GOEs are not given based on slo-mo replays.
And why he shouldn't? There is nothing in GOEs criterias about prerotation
Rika 4S is rotated in slow mo, the second 3A is borderline < and maybe they give it benefit of the doubt? Yes i noticed Anya lutz freeleg hit the ice and give the impression of 2 footed landing...
the conclusion is all of them have either very slight outside edge or flat edge... Kostornaia seems the clearest outside edge based on this pic which is kind of surprising. Zagitova sometimes have better edge (in NHK its slight outside), Bradie have flat or very very slight outside while Anna have the worst edge among them, its between flat or slight inside, i think back then it used to be better.
In real time? Nah, there isn't. What differs various lutzes between each other in eyes of common spectator is their height, distance and landing. And that is what should be reflected in scores first and foremost. Incomprehensible scores fluctuations due to invisible jump technicalities having zero impact on overall performance impressions isn't what is gonna increase fs popularity, believe me. In slo-mo? Yes, there is. But why care about slo-mo anyway? It should concern only tech specialists - not even judges since GOEs are not given based on slo-mo replays.
And why he shouldn't? There is nothing in GOEs criterias about prerotation
Even in real time, sorry to say, prerotated jumps look quite ugly. And in slow motion they are the ugliest thing - the way the skater twists and bends their body on the ice! OMG!In real time? Nah, there isn't. What differs various lutzes between each other in eyes of common spectator is their height, distance and landing. And that is what should be reflected in scores first and foremost. Incomprehensible scores fluctuations due to invisible jump technicalities having zero impact on overall performance impressions isn't what is gonna increase fs popularity, believe me. In slo-mo? Yes, there is. But why care about slo-mo anyway? It should concern only tech specialists - not even judges since GOEs are not given based on slo-mo replays.
And why he shouldn't? There is nothing in GOEs criterias about prerotation
Not going to mention the wrong edges, the full blade take off and so on - just this twisting and bending is so... OMG... I am really sad that such skaters win gold medals and other medals regularly. :'(
