What? Bradie also prerotate her lutz just as much as Young do, or maybe slightly less but she did not have have Kostner/Liza/Yuna technique lol, not even Kihira lutz technique... Her edge is not even clear and it is not called here. Also you say Yelim haven't get this kind of scores? She did get 130+ in JGP back then, when she's a JUNIOR which did not have ChSq in their program. Young FS personal best also in 140s which she achieved 2x already and now 3rd time. Have you forgot in the ladies ranking that most people put Young high and have her scoring potential up to 220 ~ 225?Also, where is usual narrative about Young You's cheating technique? I mean, young upstart with cheated prerotated lutzes won over Bradie with good jumping technique, artistry and maturity. Yet no one is complaining - nor about prerotation neither about age What's going on? Something definitely strange is happening.. :scratch3:
Also, where is usual narrative about Young You's cheating technique? I mean, young upstart with cheated prerotated lutzes won over Bradie with good jumping technique, artistry and maturity. Yet no one is complaining - nor about prerotation neither about age What's going on? Something definitely strange is happening.. :scratch3:
The scoring is just wrong. Kaori was a hot mess. Karen and Yelim should have been ahead of her.
Even though Young You needs to improve the crispness and speed of her turns in her step sequence, a need that is often not mentioned for others, she had the most expansive rink coverage. This is shown by the fact that she often skated and placed her most difficult jumps like the triple axel and triple lutz / triple toe right next to the boards, which is a rare and impressive feature that demonstrates excellent skating skills.
What? Bradie also prerotate her lutz just as much as Young do, or maybe slightly less but she did not have have Kostner/Liza/Yuna technique lol, not even Kihira lutz technique... Her edge is not even clear and it is not called here. Also you say Yelim haven't get this kind of scores? She did get 130+ in JGP back then, when she's a JUNIOR which did not have ChSq in their program. Young FS personal best also in 140s which she achieved 2x already and now 3rd time. Have you forgot in the ladies ranking that most people put Young high and have her scoring potential up to 220 ~ 225?
Of course high technical content should not result in higher PCS according to the rules outlined by the ISU, but we all know it does.. examples of this include Trusova, Sherbakova, and now Young You in the ladies. They also include a lot of male skaters who get high PCS primarily because of high technical content. Jason Brown should win the PCS scores in most competitions but he usually doesn't because skaters with more quads get higher PCS even though they have far few transitions and less impressive SS.
It is irritating but until the ISU agrees to have separate panels for the judging of PCS/TES it will continue to happen.
I am happy Young You skated well at home.
Rika and Bradie were amazing and cool headed in their freeskates
I'm pretty sure Young You cannot touch Trusova level much less Shcherbakova level of skating. I don't know where you got the idea that they are on the same level. Looking at her she should be in the the low 60's with her slow skating. Also I would never call Tennell amazing ever.
Also, where is usual narrative about Young You's cheating technique? I mean, young upstart with cheated prerotated lutzes won over Bradie with good jumping technique, artistry and maturity. Yet no one is complaining - nor about prerotation neither about age What's going on? Something definitely strange is happening.. :scratch3:
I feel like no one has ever pointed to Boyang's notoriously close-to-the-boards quad lutzes as evidence of his excellent skating skills. If anything, people have criticized those lutzes as a sign that he has bad SS, since he needs so much time and rink length to set them up.
There was definitely home scoring advantage from the judges not the technical panel. Jun was hurt by URs (something he is known for) not by the judges scores. Young You's calls were from the technical panel not thr judges. They are separate bodies.
Again, I like YY but you can't compare her skating to Bradie. Bradie has transistions and better basic skating. (although certainly not Japanese level SS). She's also performing throughout her FP. Some people find her skating boring or "wooden" but you can't really say she isn't ticking the boxes for decent PCS. (, personally, I like her SP and don't love the long but my personal preference does not eqyal PCS) Young You , on the other hand, is a great jumper and she is fast but she doesn't have transistions and pretty much ignores her choreography though large sections of the program. She shouldn't be getting 8s and 9s in PCS. But, it happens all the time. Skaters with higher technical content and those skating at home do get rewards from the judges. ( judges are separate from the technical panel)