I agree. It certainly was a broken Hallelujah. Practice will not fix it. The concept does not meet the given requirements Somewhere in there there has to be some music that sounds like a waltz. And there isn't.
While I don't adore Paul and Islam's program, at least the waltz section is a waltz.
I liked Tobias & Tkachenko's SD better than either of these programs.
Funny, I thought T/T looked cheesy and juniorish. I really preferred P/I and H/D. But say what one person's meh is another's wow