I think in the end, they were close and the win could have gone to either team really. S/S also got a -1 for an extended lift in the SD. So in the end taking the deductions out :
[...]
So if there was a clear preference from the judges today for W/P, it was in PCS. And Shibs edged on Tech, as expected. So in the end, they're close.
Good analysis, I agree with your conclusion. I just hope Chuck would let go the conspiracy theory a little bit because you know, GPF is going to be in Canada and if W/P beat S/S there, I think we are going to hear it loud, very loud...