Battle of the Sexes: TES analysis at NHK Trophy and beyond

[Baron Vladimir]

It is curious that Rika's scaled FS score would have won the FS at Rostelecom. Then again, Yuzuru essentially had 5 jumping passes.

Yes. Also, Alina would win silver (with 250 points) in Men's field at Rostelecom if her PCS are factored the same as theirs

 

[moriel]

Yes. Also, Alina would win silver (with 250 points) in Men's field at Rostelecom if her PCS are factored the same as theirs

but then i'd say this says nothing about the quality of both girls, and more about ummmm how to say it without insulting anybody what men did at Rostelecom.

 

[yume]

Rika and Alina should try the programs of those men that they virtually beat. Then there will be an accurate comparison.

 

[chopinskate]

This thread is a joke and a nightmare at the same time.

 

[withwings]

This thread is a joke and a nightmare at the same time.

Absolutely agree.
Nonsense and waste of time.

 

[lzxnl]

Rika and Alina should try the programs of those men that they virtually beat. Then there will be an accurate comparison.

If we see quads from Rika, she might soon be able to. Her coach just doesn't want her to, this season.

 

[Mohacz]

How good was ladies competition at NHK in comparison to men aka "fair results of joint competition".
I adjusted ladies components scores for men component's factor (*1/0,8) in short and free, summed up all and here you are:

1	Shoma UNO	277,45
2	Sergei VORONOV	254,28
3	Rika KIHIRA	250,25
4	Satoko MIYAHARA	246,29
5	Elizaveta TUKTAMYSHEVA	243,93
6	Mai MIHARA	228,90
7	Matteo RIZZO	225,71
8	Mariah BELL	223,90
9	Vincent ZHOU	223,42
10	Eunsoo LIM	221,09
11	Dmitri ALIEV	220,52
12	Alena LEONOVA	217,74
13	Sota YAMAMOTO	213,40
14	Maria SOTSKOVA	201,35
15	Alexander JOHNSON	199,75
16	Courtney HICKS	198,85
17	Deniss VASILJEVS	198,60
18	June Hyoung LEE	192,26
19	Hiroaki SATO	190,18
20	Mae Berenice MEITE	184,33
21	Kevin REYNOLDS	183,67
22	Angela WANG	181,84
23	Yaroslav PANIOT	175,64
24	Kailani CRAINE	174,44

I love your avatar

 

[Baron Vladimir]

Rika and Alina should try the programs of those men that they virtually beat. Then there will be an accurate comparison.

Why should they? I don't think the point of programs is to try something, but to show what you know the best. Nobody is forcing skaters to trying quads! Some strength is in hard transitions and Lo combos, some in spins and musicality, some in 3A, some in quads. The point is to be able to present them right.