- Joined
- Nov 12, 2011
Samodurova is still way better than Satoko Myahira, but never gets awarded.
Thats the point.
oof
Samodurova is still way better than Satoko Myahira, but never gets awarded.
Thats the point.
The TP ignored other “not too outside” edges too, for example those of Bradie. Hence, it was consistent.
“Our federation turned to the ISU tech committee with a question about the inconsistency of decisions - some find an edge, others do not.
Sherbakova has problems with lutz. It's reality. And here lutz jumps were not that great in USA, but they were marked as "clean". Samodurova has problems with lutz, Medvedeva has and so on. How often we could see it in protocols? It's not like judges only see mistakes of Russian skater, but never ignore them.
Inconsistency is like Pandora box. Objective scores could be really surprising for all top countries. I'm not sure they all want to see them.
That the work of tech panels has raised serious questions is the fact now rather than whining of Russian fans. Unfortunately, a reasonable explanation what lies behind this inconsistency, the one that I offered, is still considered to be a conspiracy theory.
That comes from a mistranslation.I understand the inconsistency comment that they meant it over more than one competition. Like why the TP called her edge in SA clean but in China flat edge.
That the work of tech panels has raised serious questions is the fact now rather than whining of Russian fans. Unfortunately, a reasonable explanation what lies behind this inconsistency, the one that I offered, is still considered to be a conspiracy theory.
Samodurova is still way better than Satoko Myahira, but never gets awarded.
Thats the point.
That the work of tech panels has raised serious questions is the fact now rather than whining of Russian fans.
True. It has now reached the level of whining by the Russian federation.
Of course different judges will see things differently. That's what it means to have a "judged sport." If you want a scientifically measured sport, go downhill on skis.
Samodurova is still way better than Satoko Myahira, but never gets awarded.
Thats the point.
I am actually happy they complained especially for Liza and of course for Alina ridiculous edge calls. Liza have been trying real hard this season and did not gave up even when her Fed gave up on her and this official complain is the least they can do. The judges are really trying to lower the scores of 4A and Liza. They will not make them less dominant, but trying to making scores more even by unfair calls is not right.
Oh goodness no. What a silly post. Miyahara is better. Her jumps, though not high, are woven seamlessly into the choreography of the program as a whole.
Don't get me wrong. I like Samodurova, too.
Not to mention any anti-Russian who dares to get on the podium gets bashed and complained about.
You cannot be serious.
Sasha and Anna have both scored 160+ in a GP and Alyona 159+ the highest ladies FS scores ever.
Liza also got one of her best FS scores EVER at CoC
Since when skaters got 'anti-russian'? Did you mean non-russian?
Russian skaters are bashed as well, Anna, Alina, Evgenia and Sasha too, or I don't know what is the habaloolo with endless videos/channels 'proving' they are the worst skaters in the world.
'the highest ladies FS scores ever.' with the hardest content ever. And without those calls they can earn even higher. Yes they get the placements and those calls are not effecting them (Only Liza, comparing what GEOs weaker jumper receive for their jumps), but unfair call is unfair even when you are winning.