- Joined
- Nov 2, 2013
A performance with 4 Triples is not flawed at all.
A performance with a fall is a flawed one.
However, this is nationals and when the give Giada Russo 8's for PCS than Kostner surly deserves 9's.
Pops are flaws...
A performance with 4 Triples is not flawed at all.
A performance with a fall is a flawed one.
However, this is nationals and when the give Giada Russo 8's for PCS than Kostner surly deserves 9's.
Pops are flaws...
Nope.
She can skate without any jumps or spins at all and still get the PCs.
You take points off for a mistake. Doing different content than your planned one changes only the BV (and GOE if the content is done good or bad) - but the changes itself is meaningless.
Lol then why do dictionaries define mistake as an error in action? If a pop isn't an error then why doesn't every skater just "pop" their triples into singles to make them easier to land?
Nope.
She can skate without any jumps or spins at all and still get the PCs.
You take points off for a mistake. Doing different content than your planned one changes only the BV (and GOE if the content is done good or bad) - but the changes itself is meaningless.
Because it lowers the BV and they need it for the TES.
Should a pop warrant a minus GOE? No...
If a skater plans to do a 3Lz-3T and instead does a 3Lz-2T should he automatically get negative GOE for the combo? No!
Never knew that errors, because they ARE errors, should translate to good GOEs...
seems to me that if you make a mistake, you're not executing the jump/combo well. Plus that pop might impact the height/distance, flow, and exit transitions of the jump. So yeah, I'd give it negative GOE.
Never knew that errors, because they ARE errors, should translate to good GOEs...
seems to me that if you make a mistake, you're not executing the jump/combo well. Plus that pop might impact the height/distance, flow, and exit transitions of the jump. So yeah, I'd give it negative GOE.
A performance with 4 Triples is not flawed at all.
A performance with a fall is a flawed one.
However, this is nationals and when the give Giada Russo 8's for PCS than Kostner surly deserves 9's.
Here's my question having not seen her performance.....Did she attempt more than 4 triples?? If she planned to do 4 triples and landed them with high GOE, than I don't see a problem. However, if she attempted 6 triples and either popped or doubled them, she was definitely held up...
Here's my question having not seen her performance.....Did she attempt more than 4 triples?? If she planned to do 4 triples and landed them with high GOE, then I don't see a problem. However, if she attempted 6 triples and either popped or doubled them, she was definitely held up...
She had a fall on the 3S, but landing the 3Lz was a great achievement. She sort of runs out of steam towards the end of her LPs and that's when most of her errors usually occur. Caro will be a big wildcard at the Olympics, and she could put out a great event out of nowhere, as she did in Sochi.
I think this thread is created to discuss Kostner's jumping plan. If one want to complain about her pcs at national why not do it at competition thread?
Btw, on general, pop and pcs shouldn't be correlated.