I agree with this. I am not completely sold on the idea that the judges are expected to count up a list of binary bullet points, yes or no, and that's it. I suppose one could argue that this is more "objective." But the whole point is of GOE is to reward the quality of the jump.
I wish we would see more 0's given out. The skater performed the jump adequately, did not make a major error, landed OK.
This. I would like to see on the scoring sheet them checking off the bullet points they are applying. Then adding the total up at the bottom. So you don't get to just write +3, you need to check off the bullets you are giving. IE. Good Height and Distance, difficult entry, good flow etc. Because I also feel like GOE is given arbitrarily. Yes it's subjective, but I want to see you giving a bullet for good flow then the jump lands with zero flow at all.