- Joined
- Nov 30, 2016
- Country
-
But Bradie did all her jumps with the new programs at a summer comp. So it would be weird for her to only do doubles at Camp. Unless she's dealing with a minor injury.
2018-19 U.S. Ladies' figure skating
- Thread starter Spirals for Miles
- Start date
But Bradie did all her jumps with the new programs at a summer comp. So it would be weird for her to only do doubles at Camp. Unless she's dealing with a minor injury.
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2008
Hi folks!
Just a blanket reminder
Please keep all competition chat in the Competition forums. This includes scores, starting orders, elements, links to videos, etc. Once the event is over, feel free to discuss in other Fan Fest, national threads, etc.
Should we find that folks are still discussing competition info in these threads, said threads will be closed until after the competition.
Thanks for you understanding and for supporting Golden Skate!
Just a blanket reminder
Please keep all competition chat in the Competition forums. This includes scores, starting orders, elements, links to videos, etc. Once the event is over, feel free to discuss in other Fan Fest, national threads, etc.
Should we find that folks are still discussing competition info in these threads, said threads will be closed until after the competition.
Thanks for you understanding and for supporting Golden Skate!
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2014
I remember last season it was said that at champs camp they didn’t even request to see Ashely’s la la land and just said yeah that’s fine go back to moulin rouge. Now wouldn't a federation, heading into Olympic season want to at least see some kind of run through of their biggest and most advertised lady’s new program?? Before making a decision to go back to a program that’s been used twice already? That always seemed so strange to me. And it proved to be a bad call in the end. Maybe feedback on new programs isn’t a priority for champs camp*
This is an excellent comment. Even skated perfectly Moulin was used twice and I believe that had she stayed focused on the new program from the beginning they could have made adjustments to La La Land and she would have been ready for Nationals. An Olympic year was not the time for a mid season change. It's a done deal but, it's a lesson for other skaters not make the same mistake.
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2014
- Country
-
I have no idea if Champs Camp needs improvements or not, since I’ve never been there.
Based on interviews with men, it appears they watch programs, watch run throughs as the skater chooses to skate them, and give feed back. Skaters have switched programs after Champs Camp where it actually seemed to turn out right (again, using Jason as the skater I’m most familiar with, after they saw his Secret Garden SP in 2016 he was advised to change to something else, he skated his Sam Smith exhibition, the judges said that’s better, and he made Sam Smith his SP. He did quite well with that SP. Would he have done better with Secret Garden? who knows.) So I’m not seeing where this “they’re not watching programs, they don’t get it” comes from?
And sometimes I think the pushback on Champs Camp is they are having fun, they are filming fluff, they are actually laughing, those slackers, those good for nothings, those utter losers:sarcasm:
And if only they spent all that time on programs and triples and triples and programs, we’d be winners winners winners :sarcasm:
Oh puh leeze. I think not:disapp: I actually think, from what I can tell, for what it is supposed to do, (ETA: look at programs as a whole, give the skaters time to get together in a non-competition environment, and marketing) it does that. And I think those things are important to do.
the minute it is jump da jump jump Camp, I personally would be a lot less interested....
Based on interviews with men, it appears they watch programs, watch run throughs as the skater chooses to skate them, and give feed back. Skaters have switched programs after Champs Camp where it actually seemed to turn out right (again, using Jason as the skater I’m most familiar with, after they saw his Secret Garden SP in 2016 he was advised to change to something else, he skated his Sam Smith exhibition, the judges said that’s better, and he made Sam Smith his SP. He did quite well with that SP. Would he have done better with Secret Garden? who knows.) So I’m not seeing where this “they’re not watching programs, they don’t get it” comes from?
And sometimes I think the pushback on Champs Camp is they are having fun, they are filming fluff, they are actually laughing, those slackers, those good for nothings, those utter losers:sarcasm:
And if only they spent all that time on programs and triples and triples and programs, we’d be winners winners winners :sarcasm:
Oh puh leeze. I think not:disapp: I actually think, from what I can tell, for what it is supposed to do, (ETA: look at programs as a whole, give the skaters time to get together in a non-competition environment, and marketing) it does that. And I think those things are important to do.
the minute it is jump da jump jump Camp, I personally would be a lot less interested....
And a lot of what happens in Champ Camp is not even shown to the public -- not just the monitoring sessions, but all the training/education sessions -- so it's really hard to form an opinion on it, at least for me.
The fluff stuff honestly is just that -- stuff they can show with the public, have fun with. I don't think it even speaks to what really goes on there.
The fluff stuff honestly is just that -- stuff they can show with the public, have fun with. I don't think it even speaks to what really goes on there.
I have no idea if Champs Camp needs improvements or not, since I’ve never been there.
Based on interviews with men, it appears they watch programs, watch run throughs as the skater chooses to skate them, and give feed back. Skaters have switched programs after Champs Camp where it actually seemed to turn out right (again, using Jason as the skater I’m most familiar with, after they saw his Secret Garden SP in 2016 he was advised to change to something else, he skated his Sam Smith exhibition, the judges said that’s better, and he made Sam Smith his SP. He did quite well with that SP. Would he have done better with Secret Garden? who knows.) So I’m not seeing where this “they’re not watching programs, they don’t get it” comes from?
And sometimes I think the pushback on Champs Camp is they are having fun, they are filming fluff, they are actually laughing, those slackers, those good for nothings, those utter losers:sarcasm:
And if only they spent all that time on programs and triples and triples and programs, we’d be winners winners winners :sarcasm:
Oh puh leeze. I think not:disapp: I actually think, from what I can tell, for what it is supposed to do, it does that. And the minute it is jump da jump jump Camp, I personally would be a lot less interested....
That not how I feel at all. I think the fluff and bonding good for moral. My issue is that it’s way too late. Champs camp was fine when the season technically started late October and senior B were used for warm up. Now I strongly feel since most skater will be skating at a senior B, there is just no time to change a program and have it ready by October. They need to move this back to the end of June, if they want to actually advise people to change a whole program.
There’s a LOT more I have problems with, but I’m watching the JGP so maybe later.
- Joined
- Feb 20, 2013
On another note, who's likely to get the remaining JGP slots?
Probably a repeat. Pooja or Gabriella. If Hanna has recovered, they will pencil her in. She just got on the ice for the first time the other day.
- Joined
- Feb 20, 2013
Oh.
I'm assuming they're pulling Audrey from her second event and slotting in someone else. (Coppess?)
But, depending on next week, both of them might get second events.
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2014
Audrey's current second spot should go to Pooja. Pooja has a higher score than Ting and skated cleaner. But Ting showed a lot of potential too and should keep what is currently her second spot.
The last spot should go to Gabriella if she skates well at her first assignment, or Hanna if healthy, or someone else.
The last spot should go to Gabriella if she skates well at her first assignment, or Hanna if healthy, or someone else.
Agreed.
- Joined
- Feb 12, 2017
Coppess has been mostly consistent the whole summer. None of the USA girls will make the final so I’d give 1 spot as a repeat for either ting or pooja and then give the other to Coppess. It’s better to give another person a chance in my opinion especially if none of the girls will make it to final.
Ting will be moving on next season. Hopefully by the end of this season she should have high enough WR and WS to nan two GP spots.
Ahhhhhh. I didn't realize that. I feel like all of this shows how we have not managed junior ladies well enough.
- Joined
- Sep 8, 2016
Is US Classic this week or next week? If it’s this week, I guess the US is only sending 3 ladies instead of the usual 4.
I have a question and hope somebody will be able to clarify things to me on the matter since I am a little bit confused.
If I understood correctly, there will be no novice and lower level skaters at US nationals this year. On the other hand, the decision was to increase the number of entries in juniors. And some summer club comps were supposed to be used as qualifying events to junior nationals. Now, that the summer is over, what is the results of this qualification? Have any junior ladies already qualified to nationals? Or, probably, I misunderstood something and the system works in a different way? Or these rules will come in force starting next season?
If I understood correctly, there will be no novice and lower level skaters at US nationals this year. On the other hand, the decision was to increase the number of entries in juniors. And some summer club comps were supposed to be used as qualifying events to junior nationals. Now, that the summer is over, what is the results of this qualification? Have any junior ladies already qualified to nationals? Or, probably, I misunderstood something and the system works in a different way? Or these rules will come in force starting next season?
That’s next year. This is the last year for juvenile to novice nationals.
