- Joined
- Nov 19, 2017
I believe that Tech Panel (not a Judges Panel!) work at Skate America was biased and unfair towards those two. However, noone wants to believe me and each time I try to complain - it's met with hostility. So, I decided to refrain from further accusations (if voting results/comments will show that I was wrong) and just ask pure technical question. I think that their jumps not only were called incorrectly - their landings shouldn't even warrant a review. Maybe I just have too much love for them and see what I want? See for yourself:
Judges protocols where these jumps were marked as UR you can see here: http://www.isuresults.com/results/season1920/gpusa2019/
Liza's 3Lz from SP (original video): https://youtu.be/0LLn2ERr11M?t=305
Liza's 3Lz from SP (video from other angle): https://youtu.be/-cypCFUXojI?t=88
Anna's 3Lz+3Lo from FP (original video): https://youtu.be/uGCgJlDbZ4M?t=169
Anna's 3Lz+3Lo from FP (video from other angle): https://youtu.be/X3Fs_06zT6k?t=139
I recommend to see the above videos in 0.25 slo-mo and consider both angles before making a decision. I'll try to add a poll if it's allowed here later.
P.S.: added Liza's 3Lo as well - as it got the bogus call too
https://youtu.be/tXGh7RjjFYQ?t=221
Judges protocols where these jumps were marked as UR you can see here: http://www.isuresults.com/results/season1920/gpusa2019/
Liza's 3Lz from SP (original video): https://youtu.be/0LLn2ERr11M?t=305
Liza's 3Lz from SP (video from other angle): https://youtu.be/-cypCFUXojI?t=88
Anna's 3Lz+3Lo from FP (original video): https://youtu.be/uGCgJlDbZ4M?t=169
Anna's 3Lz+3Lo from FP (video from other angle): https://youtu.be/X3Fs_06zT6k?t=139
I recommend to see the above videos in 0.25 slo-mo and consider both angles before making a decision. I'll try to add a poll if it's allowed here later.
P.S.: added Liza's 3Lo as well - as it got the bogus call too
https://youtu.be/tXGh7RjjFYQ?t=221
Last edited: