I like the Shibs' SD better. Their FD music is beautiful and they skate very well to it, but P/C has kind of mastered that genre and made it their signature style of music, so every time I see the Shibs skating to this, I just think about how P/C would do it better.
Usually I watch the female more during ice dance, but I think Alex has such a big personality on the ice that my eyes are drawn more to him. He's great!