- Joined
- Jan 10, 2016
- Country
-
So I figured I would start this thread just to see what you all though of the judging of this event. I thought it was a bit all over the place. I thought it was raining technical marks for the last 6 skaters and I thought the PCS scores were a bit over done/ underdone on some skaters. Some examples I noticed are these:
Misha Ge PCS scores are only totaling 76.92. Jin had 77. I dont see a comparison as Misha's skating is so much better than Boyang's yet he still out scored him in that department. Nam Nguyen had a score of 72 on PCS. IMO that should be closer to Boyang's score and Misha should be in the 80's for sure.
Alaine Chartrand had a PCS score of 54.. Kaetlyn and Gabby both had around 64. I dont see a 10 point difference between those 3 ladies. Honestly I was a bit shocked Gabby had the highest PCS scores in the entire competition for ladies beating out Kaetlyn. I think Kaetlyn's falls didn't help her though. When you fall that much its hard to not give up some PCS points.
Some of the technical scores surprised me a bit. Boyang received 106 in technical scores. The guy fell and had so many negative grades of execution, I dont understand how he gets over 100 points with all of those mistakes.
One more thing I'd like to point out which I found a bit funny. Judge #6 (USA) in the FD put all 3 american teams ahead of virture and moir in technique and they gave the shibs a perfect 10.00 in 2 of the PCS categories. Oh the drama is starting.. next year is the olympics.. what kind of judging debacle are we going to have this time?
Misha Ge PCS scores are only totaling 76.92. Jin had 77. I dont see a comparison as Misha's skating is so much better than Boyang's yet he still out scored him in that department. Nam Nguyen had a score of 72 on PCS. IMO that should be closer to Boyang's score and Misha should be in the 80's for sure.
Alaine Chartrand had a PCS score of 54.. Kaetlyn and Gabby both had around 64. I dont see a 10 point difference between those 3 ladies. Honestly I was a bit shocked Gabby had the highest PCS scores in the entire competition for ladies beating out Kaetlyn. I think Kaetlyn's falls didn't help her though. When you fall that much its hard to not give up some PCS points.
Some of the technical scores surprised me a bit. Boyang received 106 in technical scores. The guy fell and had so many negative grades of execution, I dont understand how he gets over 100 points with all of those mistakes.
One more thing I'd like to point out which I found a bit funny. Judge #6 (USA) in the FD put all 3 american teams ahead of virture and moir in technique and they gave the shibs a perfect 10.00 in 2 of the PCS categories. Oh the drama is starting.. next year is the olympics.. what kind of judging debacle are we going to have this time?
