- Joined
- Oct 30, 2012
Agree. Elena always manages to win at home while beaten by both Liza and Evgenia elsewhere.
2016 Rostelecom Cup - Ladies SP
- Thread starter sneakers
- Start date
Kolyada - 91 points
Radionova - personal best with an axel error
B/S - personal best by almost 4 points to try to keep pace with Chock/Bates
And that's just the shorts!
want to make bets why Satoko, Hanyu were lowballed. even C/B almost lost silver; It wasn't at Rostelecom
hmmmm....
Osmond is not a 70+s girl, that's for sure
her 132 in FS which was more over scored than even counting Gracie Gold's :shocked:
Last edited:
- Joined
- Mar 15, 2015
"An intentionally developed and/or original arrangement of all types of movements according to the principles of musical phrase, space, pattern, and structure." - I interpret this phrase as "choreography"/"musically relevant movement".
You can also find the marking guideline here: http://static.isu.org/media/1009/program-component-chart_sandp-and-id_08-16.pdf
Can't understand why so many people are against Osmond. She's skating her best ever and her personality is magic on the ice. I'm completely neutral, don't have an axe to grind, but I feel that credit should be given where it's due. Some might have put Miyahara in front of her, but she definitely deserved a podium place. I'm just so happy that she's no longer falling on all her jumps like she did last year.
Zijun's SS are not worse than Elena's or Yulia's, who are both skating on the flats ... Zijun deserves so much respect for training without a coach and still being able to skate clean. 29 PCS .. That's a shame. Such a low for an otherwise enjoyable competition ... GP's really are just homecooking events now. Crazy world we live in when the fairest judging will probably occur in cup of china ... Or TEB...
Skate Canada SP
1 Medvedeva 76 +
2 Osmond 74 + :shocked:
3 Tuktamysheva 67+
I'll rehearse that phrase:
they also had to try to put distance for Osmond between them and medal threats for her to win gold or silver
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2015
Ok, enough about Osmond.
You cannot objectively say she didn't deserve a score in the 70's for her short without making yourself seem completely unknowledgeable and irrational.
Give it a rest.
You cannot objectively say she didn't deserve a score in the 70's for her short without making yourself seem completely unknowledgeable and irrational.
Give it a rest.
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2015
My rankings:
- Pogo: She is majestic on ice. Clean performance. My score: 73
- Tursinbaeva: This tiny girl has got a lot better. She is faster, her jumps are sharper and her spins are fine. My score: 67
- Lipnitskaya: Lip had a brilliant performance tonight. Nice clean jumps. That's a pity her spins are not fast as they used to be. My score: 65
- Radianova: Her jumps are NOT improved (they probabily are worse). She URed her 3Lz-3T (which was not called by the panel). Her PCS score is way too high (I mean... 34,46 Really???) My score: 63
- Li: Clean performance. Slow. My score: 63
- Hicks: Clean performance. Iffy. My score: 62
- Pogo: She is majestic on ice. Clean performance. My score: 73
- Tursinbaeva: This tiny girl has got a lot better. She is faster, her jumps are sharper and her spins are fine. My score: 67
- Lipnitskaya: Lip had a brilliant performance tonight. Nice clean jumps. That's a pity her spins are not fast as they used to be. My score: 65
- Radianova: Her jumps are NOT improved (they probabily are worse). She URed her 3Lz-3T (which was not called by the panel). Her PCS score is way too high (I mean... 34,46 Really???) My score: 63
- Li: Clean performance. Slow. My score: 63
- Hicks: Clean performance. Iffy. My score: 62
Last edited:
- Joined
- Feb 19, 2015
Lmao aren't you guys tired of the **** measuring about home coocking 
Every GP has it deal with it
bc Someone who's overscored here are sure to be underscored somewhere else & then those same ppl would justify it as fair
Every GP has it deal with it
bc Someone who's overscored here are sure to be underscored somewhere else & then those same ppl would justify it as fair
though at the expense of Satoko who was massively dinged, not only from her underrotated jumps but low levels and a 0 point for a step sequence ! lol
Lmao aren't you guys tired of the **** measuring about home coocking
Every GP has it deal with it
bc Someone who's overscored here are sure to be underscored somewhere else & then those same ppl would justify it as fair
Except for Zijun. She will never get overinflated scores to even out her underscorings ...
The people who say that Osmond was overscored should say exactly why they think she was overscored... I've only heard two reasons(uncentered spins, unsure edge on lutz) that I find somewhat potentially valid... and she's skated in two competitions and her lutz hasn't been marked once yet and looking back from last year and it looks better now than it did before... I could tell before without freeze-framing that her lutz was inside edge and now even freeze-framing I can't tell from the angle.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2014
Why are we talking Osmond? She wasn't even here was she?
she wont get those score in any other grand prixs
how many bucks we're willing to bet here :cool14:,
Osmond will have more a realistic TES and PCS, scoring around 69+ if clean and she never had a clean FS. I doubt she will score above 200+.
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2010
Care to show us your protocol so we understand how you scored those scores?
Everyone is still up in arms about Kaetlyn at SC but where exactly does she not deserve her scores? Her jumps were big with full rotation, ice coverage was excellent, she was extremely fast (fastest of all the ladies there, I was in the arena) with lots of transitions, all the spins were fast and she got level 4's on everything. People want to say she has no reputation but performances are meant to be scored on how they performed at the time, not based on reputation. She has a huge presence on ice and performed her heart out, making lots of eye contact and projecting to the audience. Even if she got a ! on the 3Lz (I sat where her 3Lz is and it was just barely, not flat enough to be called) she would still be in the 70's.
Tuktamysheva barely had any choreography or transitions, a less difficult layout, lesser spins to Kaetlyn and her ice coverage left a lot to be desired, she deserved to be below Rika Hongo at Skate Canada.
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2015
Osmond delivered a brilliant SP last week.
She wasn't overscored.
Osmond's SP can score higher than 70 if clean.
Medvedeva was massively overscored.
because someone was bringing up hypocrisy, a canadian poster posting russians are overscored when in fact, Osmond got a massive home cooking at Skate Canada with a ridiculous score.
She is Canadian.
Similar threads
- Sticky
- Sticky
- Sticky
- Sticky
