2015 Four Continents Ladies SP Feb 13 Seoul Time
- Thread starter Mrs. P
- Start date
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2010
i know..
i'm just saying that judging in figure skating is consistent.. you know full of controversies..
- Joined
- Feb 13, 2014
Some people would give Shoma +1 GOE at most for that jump. But As BOP said, most of his jumps should have gotten 0 GOE and that's it. And seriously I have seen more than 10 people complaint that Joshua got so little GOE for his 3A.
They didn't take into account the quality of the jumps. it's like rewarding Serafima's tano jumps higher GOE than Liza's huge luzt.
Nevertheless, I never said I disagree with the placement. But the way judges give out huge GOE for so so executed jumps make me just roll my eyes.
I really like Satoko's LP. But her SP does nothing to me. And her jumps here should have been downgraded. But given into account how poorly Gracie skated, Satoko taking the lead is right IMO.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Dec 25, 2012
I picked a good time to wake up and read this thread ...
And judging by the scores, sleeping was a good idea.
It wasn't so bad. But I'm glad you got some sleep.
Polina did well. She skated a clean SP...which is better than her earlier GP skates by miles.
- Joined
- May 2, 2014
that rule isnt for 3A, axel is a must and one triple/quad(which rule addresses) and one jump combination
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2010
consider judging, I think this 4cc is already one of the less controversial.
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2012
No they don't. Please ,Satoko was underscored on the GP. Where was the so call power her federation there?
Last edited:
She's officially become my new favorite skater. If she said it looking straight into the camera, we're getting married.
Oh I made a mistake:shocked: sorry meoima and thank you mutmuh!
I know this is part of figure skating, but this smells so putrid. How could judges give Gracie -1 for the 3T landing. It was no flowing edge (of course, no place for that). In other sports you get big deductions/disqualifications, as it it considered leaving the designed area. Now, I wouldn't have killed Gracie for that mistake. But -2 or even -3 GOE would be more appropriate. That was not a good planning/position to start a jump combination. It is a mistake...+ 1A and after all this, leading the pack?!
there are, thanks to sabinfire
Thank you sabinfire!
this 4cc is another example that it takes half decade for skaters from weak federations to get proper GOE and PCS.
Just look at Zijun. Her speed and expression got much better than last comp(also skating skills!) but still judges were stingy to give her more than 30....Ugh
Just look at Zijun. Her speed and expression got much better than last comp(also skating skills!) but still judges were stingy to give her more than 30....Ugh
Last edited:
Mah... As I have said... I still think the placements overall are okay.
But the GOE they gave...
Gracie got +1.50 GOE for her step sequence, Mao only got +1.60 at the Olympics where we expect inflation
Well, at least now I know what to expect at Junior Worlds.
ITA. Her styling is terrible. That long program dress reminds me of Oksana Baiul's LP dress at the '94 Olympics. She needs to look up Michelle's styling changes from '95 to '96. I'm not saying she should do the same thing, just that she needs to see how important styling can be.
I watched Gracie's SP, thanks to Mike/Sabinfire. Wow, glad she didn't crash into the boards much as sort of tap and push away. I guess that's considered a hand-down?
To me, the rink looks huge compared to the one at Nationals, so she shouldn't have these issues, right? To be safer, she should be starting her lutz launch closer to the middle of the rink. Knowing her jumps can have huge ice coverage, this is something that they need to figure out so she doesn't wind up doubling her second jump or crashing into the boards.
Still don't see how she got 32 TES with two major mistakes. PCS I get, but the TES leaves me scratching my head, like many of you. Frank's face in the K&C said it all, even though he always looks constipated even when he's happy!
She may be able to go ahead of Satoko in the free if she is clean since they are only 2 points apart.
I also saw Zijun's skate - her laybacks are so pretty. She's one of the loveliest skaters out there.
To me, the rink looks huge compared to the one at Nationals, so she shouldn't have these issues, right? To be safer, she should be starting her lutz launch closer to the middle of the rink. Knowing her jumps can have huge ice coverage, this is something that they need to figure out so she doesn't wind up doubling her second jump or crashing into the boards.
Still don't see how she got 32 TES with two major mistakes. PCS I get, but the TES leaves me scratching my head, like many of you. Frank's face in the K&C said it all, even though he always looks constipated even when he's happy!
She may be able to go ahead of Satoko in the free if she is clean since they are only 2 points apart.
I also saw Zijun's skate - her laybacks are so pretty. She's one of the loveliest skaters out there.
Me too! Satoko looks and skates like a junior and why her PCS are higher than Polina's is a mystery to me.
Similar threads
- Sticky
- Sticky
- Sticky
- Sticky
