2022 Skate Canada Women's Short Program
- Thread starter dorispulaski
- Start date
- Joined
- Dec 8, 2020
- Country
-
Rinka's 3A and 3T were UR, 3Lz looked fine, GOE's still very low for those
Niina's 3F was fine, 3Lz+3T was q at most.
Young's 3F edge wobbled between outside and flat, but at the time of pick-in I think it was more flat, so a ! would have been a better call. I couldn't tell rotation because she landed just out of shot of the camera. Still very harsh GOE for that element as well
Niina's 3F was fine, 3Lz+3T was q at most.
Young's 3F edge wobbled between outside and flat, but at the time of pick-in I think it was more flat, so a ! would have been a better call. I couldn't tell rotation because she landed just out of shot of the camera. Still very harsh GOE for that element as well
- Joined
- Dec 3, 2014
I still don't understand. Slight wobble in the spin but nothing bad.I am off to check the spin of Lindsay Van, where it disgusted the judge so much that he gave -4 when others gave 0 and positive GOEs.
The judges have passed the delirium on to me at this point it seems. 10 mins on and still the head is reeling.
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2018
- Country
-
Some judges gave Dabin a -5 for her 3 flip at Denis Ten Memorial, it wasn´t even a stumble and for me looked great but maybe q or UR, the reason apparently edge and they actually downgraded her flip but IMO that was not more then UR
Someone explained to me that when it´s two mistakes, they have to give it -4 or -5, maybe that happen here, first mistake stumble and then another for UR = -5. It´s like you get punished double for one mistake. I don´t agree and I also think it´s very inconsistent judging from skater to skater.Rinka did not deserve this!
Last edited:
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2017
- Country
-
ISU GP Skate Canada International 2022 - Women - Short Program
www.isuresults.com
Most are known. Not that it really matters.
I was gutted for Thorngren’s pop. They really went harsh on You… I am not going to point out what is causing the extreme biases.
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2004
Anyone with peacock loose the feed?
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2018
- Country
-
As I said, I think they punish more now if there is more mistakes. For Rikas loop there was only one mistake, but for Rinkas 3A there was both a step out and UR apparently.
Same with Youngs flip, in real time for me it looked like a great jump, but she got both a edge call and q and they judges gave it -3 and -4.
This is why we see skaters get rewarded for easier but very clean element like the skater who went for 3T-3T and loop as solo jump...
Honestly I think this is really insane. Skaters take greater risk with difficult elements, for lutz and flip you are in danger of getting hammered because of both edges and rotations, and the same if you try difficult elements like quads and 3A you will be punished hard if you have rotation issues and a step out.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Apr 5, 2017
At this point I say bring on the robot tech panels... at least they won't pick favorites. (Assuming they're not programmed to ignore rotations when Daft Punk is playing or something lol
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2018
- Country
-
Just in for Skating scores, very different judging. The Korean Judge judged Rinka at 57 points and German 67 points
I will say as a former skater UR jumps are my pet peeve. I actually think not rotating in the air is the worst. I can usually see an UR from a mile away even if the skater has a nice looking hooked edge landing.
So I don’t mind getting dinged twice, one for edge and one for rotation.
I understand it’s an aesthetic sport, but it’s still a sport and rotating and hitting correct edges should matter. Just imagine back in the day someone doing a wrong edge on a figure.
So I don’t mind getting dinged twice, one for edge and one for rotation.
I understand it’s an aesthetic sport, but it’s still a sport and rotating and hitting correct edges should matter. Just imagine back in the day someone doing a wrong edge on a figure.
Just in for Skating scores, very different judges. The Korean Judge judged Rinka at 57 points and German 67 points
Those scores are nuts all over the place. I guess this is what happens when there isn’t a “favourite” or clear winner/podium like has been the case for so long.
- Joined
- Oct 20, 2017
- Country
-
I think we all need to be drunk to watch men if this scoring continues.
- Joined
- Mar 12, 2007
- Country
-
I'm so late to the party, haven't got to see anything yet, but went straight to the results, saw this, and teared up in happiness for Gabby!!!
- Joined
- Dec 8, 2020
- Country
-
The men's scores have actually been really good this season imo. I like a harsh panel, and I do agree with a lot of the calls here. I don't think Rinka's combo was -5 worthy, but it did deserve negative GOE. The one person who really got hammered was Niina, but she's not that far back after the short and should be able to climb up in the free if she skates like this againI think we all need to be drunk to watch men if this scoring continues.
- Joined
- Dec 3, 2014
Male Clown Make-up Tutorial
This Wild Clown Make-Up tutorial will transform you into a bold and comedic Clown this Halloween. With white face paint and bright yellow, blue and red face...
www.youtube.com
Saw this in live action today. Thanks, judges of the day.
Similar threads
- Sticky
- Sticky
- Sticky
