2021 Gran Premio d'Italia: Women's Free Skate

[elektra blue]

@florin stop sending people to the mental ward, here we're still wainting for you to explain us Anna's program

 

[cathlen]

well ... of course, he is no han yan but hanee is not in the KnC as a coach, at least, as far as i know

He should be here skating Anyway, I would like Poje to coach

 

[Minz]

Sorry about the delay in these last few PBP's. I had some issues with the lack of Anna's choreo sequence showing up, causing confusion. (Thanks, Peacock)

 

[onrsvm]

Everyone complaining about Liza's PCS, but no one talking about Maia's. 68 PCS for this program is a choice

 

[labgoat]

He should be here skating Anyway, I would like Poje to coach

I think he will be out in Vancouver

 

[Jontor]

@florin stop sending people to the mental ward, here we're still wainting for you to explain us Anna's program

I think @florin explained a couple of weeks ago. Could have been in the Budapest thread or the Russian Women's thread.

 

[gsk8]

#MaiiaKhromykh #GPItaly FS All new PBS! (154.31/226.35) "I am satisfied and at the same time not. I made an error on the loop and the footwork was not so good. The second place is not bad, I will strive for victory in the future."

 

[readernick]

Everyone complaining about Liza's PCS, but no one talking about Maia's. 68 PCS for this program is a choice

Yes, and no. I hate the music but I do actually feel that the choreo matches the music better than Anna's. Anyway, she landed two quads. The judges were going to reward her... right, no. Expected, yes!

 

[meadow]

I'm so happy for Loena, her reactions when she ended the program and then later in the K&C were so sweet

 

[4everchan]

Everyone complaining about Liza's PCS, but no one talking about Maia's. 68 PCS for this program is a choice

i will only speak for myself :
1) I do not compare scores from competition to competition... different panels... which leads to
2) there is not much point referring to skaters who are not competing this week in this particular thread is it?
3) since you are asking, they are both overscored probably but at least, Liza performs the hell out of her programs. Maiia just skated through...
YMMV

 

[elektra blue]

I think @florin explained a couple of weeks ago. Could have been in the Budapest thread or the Russian Women's thread.

probably russian women, i know my memory is bad but i don't remember anything at all anyway i hope he doesn't mind explaining it again

 

[4everchan]

I think he will be out in Vancouver

??? what do you mean?

 

[Tolstoj]

Everyone complaining about Liza's PCS, but no one talking about Maia's. 68 PCS for this program is a choice

I had her below Mai in components but not by much.

So maybe 1-2 points overmarked.

 

[Minz]

#11

Maiia KHROMYKH

RUS

1. 4 Toe + 2 Toe
2. 4 Toe
3. Change Combination Spin 4
4. 3 Loop (2ft)
5. 2 Axel
6. Step Sequence 2
7. 3 Lutz + 3 Toe
8. 3 Flip + Euler + 3 Salchow
9. 3 Lutz
10. Flying Camel Spin 4
11. Choreo Sequence
12. Flying Change Combination Spin 4

TES: 85.77
PCS: 68.54
Deductions: 0.00

Total Segment Score: 154.31 (85.77 + 68.54)

Total Competition Score: 226.35 (72.04 + 154.31)

 

[labgoat]

??? what do you mean?

Poje was joining the coaching staff of an arena in Kelowna

Olympic figure skater to coach in Kelowna

Kelowna Skating Club and Centre of Excellence says it is thrilled to announce the addition of a high-profile Olympian to their coaching team.

www.kelownadailycourier.ca

 

[RatedPG]

Very good event. I’m satisfied with the results. Anna S. is such a fighter. She really attacked that 4F and landed it. Congrats to her and a well deserved gold. She has shown why she was undefeated last year and this performance at this event really helps her out in terms of only adding to her resume. Maia was brilliant, as well, with her two 4T’s. This quad jump is becoming really solid for her. She doesn’t get as much flow from her jumps. She is right now a solid #5 in regards to the Senior Ladies ranks. Loena, though, was the performance of the day for me. I nervously watched as she nailed triple after triple. That is the best she can do. She was so happy with her well deserved bronze medal. Is she the best non-Russian lady? Brilliant performance from her. Finally, I was so happy with the two Japanese skaters. They are both such warriors. They are so consistent even though their jumps are so tiny. I love how Mai with two 4th place finishes is really making a strong case to be chosen for the Olympics. Miyahara, well, that was much better than what she produced at Skate America. Excellent event.

 

[onrsvm]

i will only speak for myself :
1) I do not compare scores from competition to competition... different panels... which leads to
2) there is not much point referring to skaters who are not competing this week in this particular thread is it?
3) since you are asking, they are both overscored probably but at least, Liza performs the hell out of her programs. Maiia just skated through...
YMMV

1. I have just shared my opinion considering GP Season, so I do not think that speaking of previous week is inappropriate.
2. Yes the marks varies from competition to competition, but as you know the judging is quite similar in GP series. Thus, I do compare scores from com. to com.
3. I agree with you

 

[eterialskating]

Everyone complaining about Liza's PCS, but no one talking about Maia's. 68 PCS for this program is a choice

First of all Maiia looks like a much more polished and mature skater than Tuk who's not shown any progress in her performance ability. The same tired cabaret act since I can remember. And they are not even scored the same so why bring it up. Tuktamysheva is scored in the 70+ like Anna and Kamila and more than Kostornaya this season. So no I don't buy this faux outrage on Maiia's PCS.

 

[Minz]

#12

Loena HENDRICKX

BEL

1. 3 Lutz + 3 Toe
2. 2 Axel
3. 3 Flip
4. 2 Axel
5. Change Combination Spin 4
6. Step Sequence 4
7. 3 Lutz + 2 Toe
8. 3 Flip + 2 Toe + 2 Loop
9. 3 Salchow
10. Layback Spin 4
11. Choreo Sequence
12. Flying Change Combination Spin 4

TES: 74.91
PCS: 70.62
Deductions: 0.00

Total Segment Score: 145.53 (74.91 + 70.62)

Total Competition Score: 219.05 (73.52 + 145.53)

 

[onrsvm]

First of all Maiia looks like a much more polished and mature skater than Tuk who's not shown any progress in her performance ability. The same tired cabaret act since I can remember. And they are not even scored the same so why bring it up. Tuktamysheva is scored in the 70+ like Anna and Kamila and more than Kostornaya this season. So no I don't buy this faux outrage on Maiia's PCS.

Even Mai and Satako barely getting these scores. How Maiia got 68 in her first senior debut? Is she more mature and polished skater than Satako and Mai? The PCS completely depends on Technical content nothing related about artistry and presentation. We all witnessed many times